‎Dr. Daniel W. Guthrie‏‎ 1) 2), son of William Guthrie and Sarah Ann [--?--]‏. Born ‎± 1866 at PA‎ 3) 4), died ‎ 1898 at DuBois, Clearfield Co. PA‎, approximately 32 years 1) Census (‎ 1870 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Living with parents and siblings. 2) Census (‎ 1880 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Living with parents and siblings. 4) Located: (‎ Mar 1888 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Teacher. 3) Married ‎ Mar 27, 1888 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA 1) 3) (9 or 10 years married) to: ‎Elizabeth Jane McColgin‏‎ 5) 6) 1) 7), daughter of Thomas Dubois McColgin and Mary Sterling Marshall‏. Born ‎ Jul 27, 1867 at Meredith, Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA‎ 6) 1) 8) 9), died ‎ Sep 17, 1934 at Peoria, Peoria Co. IL‎, 67 years 1) 8) 9), buried ‎ at Springdale Cemetery and Mausoleum, Peoria, Peoria Co. IL 1) 9), ‎1st marriage to: Dr. Daniel W. Guthrie, ‎2nd marriage to: James Edward Smith On the 1900and 1910 censuses, Elizabeth states that she has had one child, and the child is living. 10) 12) Census (‎ 1870 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Living with parents, siblings, paternal grandmother and farm laborer Wesley Keith (b. abt 1850 in PA). 6) Census (‎ 1880 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Living on the farm with parents and siblings. 13) Located: (‎ Mar 1888 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) 3) Census (‎ 1900 at Earlville, LaSalle Co. IL) Living with second husband James E. Smith and daughter. 10) Census (‎ 1910 at Arcola, Douglas Co. IL) Living with daughter Edna and her family. 12) Census (‎ 1920 at Peoria, Peoria Co. IL) Seamstress in an apron factory. Living with husband. 14) Located: (‎ Jul 1928 at San Antonio, Bexar Co. TX) Informant for husband James E. Smith's death certificate; living at 11 Delmar in San Antonio. 15) Child: 1. ‎Mary Edna Guthrie‏‎ 1) 16) Born ‎ Jun 1888 at Meredith, Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA‎ 16) 10) 17), died ‎ 1979‎, 90 or 91 years 17), buried ‎ at Arcola Township Cemetery, Arcola, Douglas Co. IL 17) On the 1910 census, Edna states that she has had one child, and the child is living. 12) Census (‎ 1900 at Earlville, LaSalle Co. IL) Living with mother and stepfather. 10) Located: (‎ Sep 1908 at Arcola, Douglas Co. IL) 16) Census (‎ 1910 at Arcola, Douglas Co. IL) Living with husband, son and mother. 12) Census (‎ 1920 at Detroit, Wayne Co. MI) Living with husband and sons. 18) Located: (‎ Sep 1934 at Peoria, Peoria Co. IL) 1)

Sources

1) source: Mrs. Elizabeth Jane Smith
2) source: 1870 U.S. Census Population Schedule, Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA, extra text: \par, page: Page 114-A (Stamped), Dwelling 196, Family 198, William Guthrie Family
3) source: Marriage License and Certificate of D. W. Guthrie and Lizzie J. McColgin, extra text: \par
4) source: 1880 U.S. Census Population Schedule, Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA, extra text: \par, page: ED 4, Sheet 102-D, Dwelling 376, Family 389, William Guthrie Family
5) source: The Marshall Family: A History of the Descendants of William Marshall (Born 1722, Died 1796), page: p. 231
6) source: 1870 U.S. Census Population Schedule, Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA, page: Page 106-B (Stamped), Dwelling 82, Family 85, Thomas McColgin Family
7) source: Armstrong County, Pennsylvania: Her People, Past and Present, Vol. 2
8) source: Illinois Deaths and Stillbirths Index, 1916-1947, extra text: Name: Elizabeth Jane Smith [Elizabeth Jane McColgin]\parBirth Date: 27 Jul 1867\parBirth Place: Meredith, Penn\parDeath Date: 17 Sep 1934\parDeath Place: Peoria, Peoria, Illinois\parBurial Date: 20 Sep 1934\parBurial Place: Peoria, Peoria, Illinois\parCemetery Name: Springdale\parDeath Age: 67\parRace: White\parMarital Status: W\parGender: Female\parStreet Address: 611 Second\parFather Name: Thomas D. McColgin\parFather Birth Place: Penn.\parMother Name: Mary Marshall\parSpouse Name: James E. Smith\parFHL Film Number: 1712120 \par, page: Entry for Elizabeth Jane Smith
9) source: Find-a-Grave, page: Memorial for Elizabeth Jane McColgin Smith (Memorial # 170875596)
10) source: 1900 U.S. Census Population Schedule, Earlville, LaSalle Co. IL, page: ED 47, Sheet 10-A, Dwelling 229, Family 236, James E. Smith Family
11) source: Obituary of James Smith
12) source: 1910 U.S. Census Population Schedule, Arcola, Douglas Co. IL, page: ED 87, Sheet 4-A, Dwelling 74, Family 75, Ervin Snyder Family
13) source: 1880 U.S. Census Population Schedule, Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA, page: ED 4, Sheet 109-A, Dwelling 490, Family 508, T.D. McColgin Family
14) source: 1920 U.S. Census Population Schedule, Peoria, Peoria Co. IL, page: ED 77, Sheet 2-B, Dwelling 43, Family 45, John E. Smith Family
15) source: Death Certificate of James Edw Smith
16) source: Marriage License and Certificate of Ervin Lewis Snyder and Mary Edna Guthrie
17) source: Find-a-Grave, page: Memorial for Mary Edna Guthrie Snyder (Memorial # 40948501)
18) source: 1920 U.S. Census Population Schedule, Detroit, Wayne Co. MI, page: ED 479, Sheet 1-B, Dwelling 22, Family 23, Erven L. Snyder Family

Citation for: Family Page
"Family Page: Daniel W. Guthrie & Elizabeth Jane McColgin." HuMo-genealogy - A Rural Valley and Cowanshannock Family Tree (http://www.ruralvalleyhistory.com/family.php?tree_id=37&id=F1725&main_person=I5138 : accessed 07 March 2026) Daniel W. Guthrie #I5138, born ‎± 1866 at PA