man‎William McGaughey‏‎ 1) 2) 3), son of William McGaughey and Mary "Polly Blair" Blair‏.
Born ‎ May 18, 1829‎ 2) 3), died ‎before 1880‎, at most 51 years
Death date estimate based on Elvira's status as widow on 1880 census. 4)
Census (‎ 1850 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Living with parents and siblings. 3)
Census (‎ 1860 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Farmer. Living with wife. 5)
Census (‎ 1870 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Farm laborer, living with his family on the farm of Anthony Gallagher. 6)

Married ‎± 1861 2) to:

womanElvira "Albina Casedy, Alvira Casedy" Casedy‏ 7) 8) 9) 1), daughter of Samuel "Samuel Casada, Samuel Casady, Samuel Cassidy" Casedy and Matilda Campbell‏.
Born ‎ Jun 10, 1840 at PA‎ 7) 9), died ‎± Apr 1884‎, approximately 43 years 1)
Census (‎ 1850 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Living with parents and siblings. 9)
Census (‎ 1860 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Living with husband. 5)
Census (‎ 1870 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Living with husband and children. 6)
Census (‎ 1880 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Widowed. Living with children Winfield, Samuel, Tillie and Laura Belle. 4)

Children:

1.
man‎Winfield Pettigrew McGaughey‏‎ 1)
Born ‎± 1861 at PA‎ 4)
Census (‎ 1870 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Living with parents and siblings. 6)
Census (‎ 1880 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Laborer. Living with mother and siblings. 4)

2.
man‎Arthur C. McGaughey‏‎ 2)
Born ‎± 1864‎ 10), died ‎before 1884‎ 2)
Birth year is an estimate only. I have no idea where Arthur falls in the birth order of the children. In the Marshall Family History, he is listed as a child of William and Elvira's but without a birth date; he was dead by the time the book was published. He is not listed on the 1880 census with the rest of the family. 2) 4)

3.
manSamuel Casedy McGaughey‏ 1) 11) 8)
Born ‎ Mar 5, 1867 at PA‎ 12) 4) 13), died ‎ Sep 12, 1925 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA‎, 58 years 12) 13) 14), buried ‎ at Rural Valley Cemetery, Rural Valley, Armstrong Co. PA 12) 13) 14)
Census (‎ 1870 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Living with parents and siblings. 6)
Census (‎ 1880 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Living with mother and siblings. 4)
Located: (‎ Sep 1888 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Laborer. 15)
Census (‎ 1900 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Farmer. Living with wife and children. 16)
Census (‎ 1910 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Farmer. Living with wife and children. 17)
Census (‎ 1920 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Farmer. Living with wife and sons. 18)

4.
womanMargaret Matilda Jane "Tillie McGaughey" McGaughey‏ 1) 19)
Born ‎ Mar 1870 at PA‎ 20) 21) 4), died ‎ Feb 3, 1945 at Sistersville, Tyler Co. WV‎, 74 years 20), buried ‎ at Greenwood Cemetery, Sistersville, Tyler Co. WV 22)
On the 1900 census, Matilda states that she is the mother of one child, and that child is living.

On the 1910 census, Matilda's information about number of children is missing.
21) 23)
Census (‎ 1870 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Living with parents and siblings. 6)
Census (‎ 1880 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Living with mother and siblings. 4)
Census (‎ 1900 at Sistersville, Tyler Co. WV) Living with husband and child. 21)
Census (‎ 1910 at Sistersville, Tyler Co. WV) Bread (?) maker, working at home. Head of household but still listed as married. Living with two children. 23)
Located: (‎ Jan 1928 at Sistersville, Tyler Co. WV) 19)
Located: (‎ Sep 1933 at Sistersville, Tyler Co. WV) 24)

5.
womanLaura Belle McGaughey‏ 1)
Born ‎ Nov 1872 at PA‎ 25) 26), died ‎ Jan 22, 1928 at Kittanning, Armstrong Co. PA‎, 55 years 27) 19), buried ‎ at Kittanning Cemetery, Kittanning, Armstrong Co. PA 27)
On the 1910 census, Laura states that she has had no children. 28)
Census (‎ 1880 at Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA) Living with mother and siblings. 4)
Census (‎ 1900 at Kittanning, Armstrong Co. PA) Servant. Living in the home of Harry, relationship listed as boarder, so perhaps working as a servant elsewhere. 26)
Located: (‎ Oct 1902 at Kittanning, Armstrong Co. PA) Domestic worker. 29)
Census (‎ 1910 at Wickboro, Armstrong Co. PA) Living with husband and sister-in-law Sadie. 28)
Census (‎ 1920 at Kittanning, Armstrong Co. PA) Living with husband. 30)
Located: (‎ Sep 1925 at Kittanning, Armstrong Co. PA) 14)


Sources

1) source: Will of Elvira (Casedy) McGaughey
2) source: The Marshall Family: A History of the Descendants of William Marshall (Born 1722, Died 1796)
3) source: 1850 U.S. Census Population Schedule, Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA, page: Page 231-B (Stamped), Dwelling 147, Family 149, William McGaughey Family
4) source: 1880 U.S. Census Population Schedule, Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA, page: ED 4, Sheet 92-D, Dwelling 185, Family 188, E. McGaughey Family
5) source: 1860 U.S. Census Population Schedule, Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA, page: Page 158 (Stamped), Dwelling 1577, Family 1575, Wm. McGaughey Family
6) source: 1870 U.S. Census Population Schedule, Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA, page: Page 107-A (Stamped), Dwelling 91, Family 94, Anthony Gallagher Residence
7) source: Family Bible of Samuel and Matilda Casedy
8) source: Will of Samuel C. Cassidy
9) source: 1850 U.S. Census Population Schedule, Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA, page: Page 232-A (Stamped), Dwelling 180, Family 183, Samuel Casada Family
10) source: Birth date estimate
11) source: Obituary of Beryl C. McGaughey
12) source: Death Certificate of Samuel C. McGaughey
13) source: Find-a-Grave, page: Memorial for Samuel Cassidy McGaughey (Memorial # 81043796)
14) source: S. C. McGaughey Dead At Home Near Bryan
15) source: Marriage License and Certificate of Samuel C. McGaughey and Anna Mary Casedy
16) source: 1900 U.S. Census Population Schedule, Cowanshannock Twp. (South Division), Armstrong Co. PA, page: ED 2, Sheet 12-A, Dwelling 226, Family 231, Samuel C. McGaughey Family
17) source: 1910 U.S. Census Population Schedule, Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA, page: ED 9, Sheet 5-A, Dwelling 84, Family 85, Samuel C. McGaughey Family
18) source: 1920 U.S. Census Population Schedule, Cowanshannock Twp., Armstrong Co. PA, page: ED 5, Sheet 11-B, Dwelling 200, Family 201, S.C. McGaughey Family
19) source: Mrs. Charles A. Wolfe Is Summoned
20) source: Death Record of Matilda (McGaughey) Tibbens
21) source: 1900 U.S. Census Population Schedule, Sistersville City (Ward 3), Lincoln District, Tyler Co. WV, page: ED 87, Sheet 10-A, Dwelling 186, Family 192, Harry Tibbins Family
22) source: Find-a-Grave, page: Memorial for Matilda J. Tibbins (Memorial # 43911836)
23) source: 1910 U.S. Census Population Schedule, Sistersville, Lincoln District, Tyler Co. WV, page: ED 99, Sheet 5-B, Dwelling 85, Family 90, Tillie Tibbins Family
24) source: Marriage License and Certificate of Harry C. Tibbens and Ruth Snodgrass
25) source: Find-a-Grave, page: Memorial for Laura B. Wolfe (Memorial # 92451538)
26) source: 1900 U.S. Census Population Schedule, Kittanning Borough (Ward 2), Armstrong Co. PA, page: ED 19, Sheet 25-B, Dwelling 494, Family 503, Harry R. Gault Family
27) source: Death Certificate of Laura L. Wolfe
28) source: 1910 U.S. Census Population Schedule, Wickboro, Armstrong Co. PA, page: ED 51, Sheet 11-A, Dwelling 196, Family 204, Charley A. Wolfe Family
29) source: Marriage License and Certificate of Laura McGaughey and Charles Wolfe
30) source: 1920 U.S. Census Population Schedule, Kittanning Borough (Ward 4), Armstrong Co. PA, page: ED 29, Sheet 3-A, Dwelling 50, Family 51, Charles Wolff Family

Citation for: Family Page
"Family Page: William McGaughey & Elvira Casedy." HuMo-genealogy - A Rural Valley and Cowanshannock Family Tree (http://www.ruralvalleyhistory.com/family.php?tree_id=36&id=F1218&main_person=I3634 : accessed 17 June 2025) William McGaughey #I3631, born ‎ May 18, 1829


Not finding your family? Click here for more genealogy resources